Tag: Research

A greatest scientist I ever met

Jackson School of Geosciences. In Austin, Texas. A quiet person, like a saint. Went to Harvard for his undergraduate degree. Completed his graduate studies from MIT. A pioneer scientist still teaching in his 80’s.

He never said no to his students. He never disagreed with his students. He would just listen to the presenter and provide his comments in the end in his low voice. One had to listen very carefully to understand what he would say. He would always give a big advice in a simple language.

Dr. Robert Dickinson is one of the greatest scientist in the field of climate modeling. His papers have received more than 50,000 citations to date. I was fortunate enough to have him in my PhD qualifying and dissertation committee. My PhD supervisor Zong-Liang Yang was once supervised by him. So he is like my grandfather in the research world.

A picture taken after my PhD defense on April 15, 2016. Dr. Dickinson is at the right end.

In my PhD qualifying exam, he didn’t give me any comments. He only said — build on the existing knowledge, than create something entirely new. He was basically saying that — do your research standing on the shoulders of giants. It was a very important suggestion to me because at that time I was trying to propose/develop a new map to characterize dust sources that could be used in climate models. And at that time, I didn’t really know how challenging it could be. I just wanted to talk ‘big’ because I had to do it to continue my PhD. It was indeed my ignorance, fueled somewhat by my ego. His advice immediately brought me down, to the ground.

He received his PhD in 1966. He then worked at NCAR for more than 20 years. In the late 70’s he noticed that the ‘land’ parts of the global climate models were the worst. It was indeed true because at that time, climate models mainly focused on large-scale atmospheric circulations such as Hadley cells. They overlooked the importance of land perhaps because more than 70% of Earth’s surface is ocean and assumed that land would have little role on modifying the atmosphere.

But he thought it was not right. Land was indeed important and it was not right to ignore it from the equations of the Earth System. Is there no role of land vegetation on the atmospheric dynamics? What about the role of aerosols that originate from lands? Well, we humans live on lands so without representing it how would anything be complete?

So he started working on improving the land component of the climate models. He is particularly known for the land model that he developed called BATS (Biosphere atmosphere transfer scheme) in which he modeled how biosphere exchanges energy with the atmosphere.

If you look at the history of most creative scientists, you will see that they all have a few single-author papers. No wonder, Dr. Dickinson has many such articles which you can find in his Google Scholar page. In one of his single-authored articles, the abstract consists of only 2 sentences. I have never seen any abstract shorter than that. That shows, how straight he was to the point.

Yesterday, I read one of his paper that he published in 1983, while I was reviewing the literature on ‘surface albedo’ characterization in climate models. Apparently, I was 1 year old at that time. In that paper, he goes into so much details about the importance and complexity of representing surface albedo in climate models. And that is why I am writing about him today.

Understanding publication metrics: impact factor and h-index

I was looking for some papers in Google Scholar yesterday and accidentally clicked on ‘Metrics’ icon located on the right side of the page. In front of me was a list of top 100 journals (of the world) based on their h-index. I was surprised to see that most of the journals in the list were in the field of biological sciences, physics, and chemistry. To my dismay, I didn’t see the journal ‘Nature Geosciences’, the most revered (sorry if you don’t like to say so) journal in the field of Geosciences. But do the above results imply that only the ladies and gentlemen in biology, physics, and chemistry publish good research? Does that mean Geo-scientists watch movies all the time?

The answer is certainly “no”.

111

So the question is:

Why the journals in biology, physics, and chemistry have the highest impact factor? 

To answer this question, we have to answer another question first:

What exactly is an h-index?

According to Wikipedia, “A scientist has index h if h of his/her Np papers have at least h citations each, and the other (Np − h) papers have no more than h citations each.”

Little confused? Very reasonable! But it is very simple.

If a scientist has an h-index of 12, it means that he/she has published 12 papers that received 12 or more citations.

The h-index was proposed by physicist Jorge E. Hirsh in 2005 aiming to measure both the productivity and citation impact.

So to maintain a high h-index, you have to keep publishing while maintaining the quality of your publications (so that you receive more citations). If you publish a paper that is eventually not cited, you are wasting your time as it won’t contribute to your h-index no matter how many more such papers you publish. The h-index for a journal also means the same thing.

Now we are in a situation to answer the original question. If a journal has a high h-index, it generally means that it has published higher number of papers that received higher number of citations. But what does that really mean? It simply means that there are more people working in that field so that the probability of number of papers being published (and cited) is higher.

Still doesn’t make sense? Lets look at this statistics here about the number of PhDs awarded in 2008 (of course in the US). The number of doctorates awarded in biological sciences is 7,793 while it is 862 for earth, atmospheric, and ocean sciences. So obviously we can expect more publications in biological sciences, and hence more citations, and hence higher h-index, in the journals of that field. This is not surprising considering the fact that the history of research in biological sciences, physics, and chemistry is much longer than that of Geosciences. I hope I answered the original question.

Unfortunately, h-index is not perfect as is this world. For example, if a scientist published only one paper in his life time that received say 2,000 citations, his h-index is 1. Another scientist who published one paper and received only 15 citations, would still have an h-index of 1. Another drawback of these metrics including the h-index is that they do not reflect the difference among different fields. So the h-index of a journal/professor of biology cannot be compared to the h-index of a professor/journal of Geosciences.

In your Google Scholar profile, you will also see another index called i10-index developed by google, which, in fact, is very similar to the h-index. It is just the number of your papers that received at least 10 citations.

Another frequently asked question:

Do you really need to publish in a journal having a very high impact factor to prove yourself?

The answer is “not really”. Have you realized that the impact factor of your paper may be higher or lower than the impact factor of the journal itself?

According to Wikipedia, the impact factor of a journal in any given year is the average number of citations received per paper published in that journal during the two preceding years. So if a journal has a high impact factor, either the journal received higher number of citations or the journal accepted fewer number of articles, or it could be both. For most of the journals, the acceptance ratio would not be too much different. So the major component affecting the impact factor is the number of citations indeed.

Lets take an example of a paper published in 2013. This paper published in April 2013 has received 25 citations until July 2015. That means the impact factor of this paper is 25. Note that the impact factor of the journal Nature in which this paper was published is 41.45 in 2014. So it can be said that this paper is significantly below average for this journal.

Lets take another contrasting example. This paper has received 50 citations in a similar time period, i.e., between May 2013 to July 2015. This means that the impact factor of this paper is 50. Now compare this to the impact factor of the JGR-Atmosphere journal in which it was published, i.e., 3.43. It means that this paper has significantly higher impact than the journal’s average impact.

So it really doesn’t matter in which journal you publish your paper. The only thing that matters is whether you receive citations or not.

One last question:

What is the best way to measure productivity of a researcher?

There will probably be many indices rolling in the future each claiming that it is the best. But, perhaps the best way to evaluate a researcher’s productivity or performance is to simply look at both the number of citations and the number of publications, both of which are shown by Google Scholar and other academic search engines (if made public). In addition, quality of the paper must be evaluated by a researcher in that field. It is that simple. I am not saying that we don’t need those indices. When making comparison among many candidates, those indices are indeed very helpful. And it is always fun to compare your index with that of your peers in Google Scholar. 🙂

Thank you for reading.

P.S.: The original paper about the h-index can be found here.

The author is thankful to Travis Swanson for helpful discussion.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén

Secret Link